How to Collect and Use Testimonials Effectively to Grow Your Membership Site

One effective way to grow your membership program, whether you’re just starting out or are already well established, is to publish testimonials from your members on your website.

Used in the right way, testimonials can make your membership program look more credible, help highlight its best features, and provide some much needed social proof to persuade your visitors to take a chance on your content.

While there’s much to gain from adding testimonials to your membership site, collecting and publishing feedback from your members isn’t always straightforward.

However, if you follow the advice in this guide, you should be well on your way to growing your membership site through the use of testimonials.

Why Bother With Testimonials?

Example of a testimonial

We’ve covered some of the reasons why publishing testimonials on your membership site is a good idea in previous articles on this blog, including how to use feedback to improve your conversion rates and ways to make your membership website look more professional.

However, to summarise, positive testimonials can have a powerful effect on the conversion rates of your membership site, helping to turn more of your website visitors into paying members.

Used properly, testimonials can answer questions your potential members might have, highlight your experience and knowledge, and signal that it’s safe to enter payment details into your system.

If you’re proud of your membership site and its content, then there’s really no reason why you shouldn’t be publishing testimonials on your website. So to help you get started, this guide includes tips and advice on how you can go about collecting and using testimonials to grow your membership site.

Let's begin…

Ask at the Right Time

Due to the many benefits of publishing testimonials on your website, you might be tempted to ask for feedback from your members right away. However, in this instance, being so proactive isn’t a good idea.

Instead, give your members time to access your content, and if necessary, ask for your help. Once they’ve had a chance to benefit from your membership site, as well as experience your top-quality customer service, they’ll be much more willing — and able — to provide genuine positive feedback.

Make It Easy for Your Members

While you could simply fire off an email to your members asking them what they think of your membership program, this approach probably won’t yield the best results.

Instead, you should try to make it as easy as possible for your members to provide feedback.

Creating a purpose-built online form for collecting feedback with a plugin like WPForms is a great way to simplify the process. Not only does this give you the opportunity to get the type of feedback you’re most interested in, but you can use the advanced features of such a plugin to add feedback fields to your forms that let visitors rate your site at the touch of a button.

Collect testimonials with a purpose-built form.

Now that we’ve covered how to collect the feedback, let’s look at some of the information you should try to get from your members…

Ask Your Members about Their Experiences

To receive the type of feedback that can be used as an effective testimonial, you need to ask the right questions.

Instead of simply asking your users what they thought about your membership site, encourage them to talk about their experiences.

Ask questions that prompt them to explain why they signed up in the first place, how your program helped them, and what results they achieved after putting your advice into practice.

Some other suggestions for questions to ask include whether they had any reservations before signing up, and if so, how your membership site allayed their concerns. You could also ask if they’d recommend your program, and if so, to whom.

Remember, you don’t have to publish all of their feedback, but the more questions you ask, the more material you’ll have to work with. However, don’t overdo it by asking too much from your members and risk them being overwhelmed and refusing to engage with your request. Less is more when it comes to asking a favor from your members.

To make your testimonials more engaging and trustworthy, be sure to ask for a photo from your members as well as a link to their website or social media profile so your visitors can verify that the feedback is genuine.

Text is Good but Video is Better

Some reports claim that including video on your landing pages can increase conversions by over 80%, compared to simply publishing feedback in text format on your website.

However, not all, if any, of your members will be willing or able to produce a video testimonial for your website. Therefore, due to the effort and knowledge required to create a video testimonials, it’s not recommended that you ask for this form of feedback from all of your members by default.

Instead, wait until you receive some really great written feedback from a member, then follow up and ask them personally if they’d be prepared to make a short video testimonial for your website.

Also, any members you’ve worked with closely and formed a good relationship with, especially those who you know have gotten great results from your content could be a good candidate for a video testimonial.

As creating a video can be time consuming, technically demanding, and a little daunting, you’ll probably have to support your members in producing their video feedback. This could include providing them with prompts of what to say based on their written feedback, helping them with choosing and using a video recording app, and scheduling a video interview which you can edit into a short testimonial for your site.

You might even have to try offering potential candidates some kind of incentive for them to take the time to provide a video. This could come in the form of reduced membership fees, access to another of your programs, or some bonus content.

Publish the Testimonials On Your Website

Studio Pro WordPress Theme Testimonials

Last but not least, make sure you publish the testimonials as soon as you start receiving them. Don’t wait until you’ve received multiple responses from your members. Instead, put this valuable content to work right away.

Even if the first few responses you receive aren’t amazing, as long as they're positive, you should publish these testimonials on your site. You can always replace them later, once you’ve refined your process for asking for feedback and start receiving more impressive testimonials.

When it comes to actually publishing the testimonials on your membership site, one option is to use a free plugin like Jetpack and its testimonials module. Alternatively, you can use a purpose-built testimonials plugin, or simply create a new page and add the feedback in plain text format.

When publishing the testimonials, try to include as many details as possible, such as the full name of the member, a photo, and a website address or link to their social media profile so that your visitors can verify for themselves who the testimonial is from. Don't forget to get approval before publishing the testimonial, especially if you've made any edits.

Finally, don’t just create a page for your testimonials and store all your feedback there.

Instead, publish your best feedback on the homepage of your website and on your signup pages. By displaying your glowing testimonials front and center, you can deploy them where they’ll be most effective in growing your membership site, such as at the point where you ask your visitors to take action and sign up or enter their payment details.

Final Thoughts

Hopefully, these tips on collecting and using testimonials to promote your membership site have been useful.

You should now be ready to start effectively asking for feedback from your users and then publishing it so it has the greatest positive impact on your membership site conversion rates.

If your membership site is yet to secure its first members, then you could always consider offering free access to your program in exchange for honest feedback. Although you wouldn’t generate any revenue directly from these members, their feedback could prove invaluable when it comes to promoting your membership site.

Are you ready to start asking your members for feedback?

Affiliate Link Disclosure

Categories: Advice
About Joe Fylan

Joe uses WordPress to create websites of all types and loves sharing his experiences of using this software with other users. If you need a steady stream of great content for your website, or you want the latest WordPress news and reviews check out his writing services and WordPress blog.