Mighty Networks built its reputation on community. MemberPress just caught up, and it’s doing it for a fraction of the price, on a platform you actually own.
The Short Answer: MemberPress is a WordPress plugin starting at $299.50/year that now includes full community features (discussion boards, member directories, and real-time messaging) via ClubSuite™, all on a site you own.
Mighty Networks is a standalone SaaS platform starting at $79/month that leads with community and mobile.
MemberPress wins on cost, data ownership, and flexibility for WordPress users.
Mighty Networks wins on mobile experience and all-in-one simplicity for those who don’t want to manage hosting.
At a Glance: MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks
| Feature | MemberPress | Mighty Networks |
|---|---|---|
| Platform ownership / data | You own everything (WordPress) | Hosted SaaS (data stays on their servers) |
| Starting price (community plan) | $299.50/year | $79/month (~$948/year) |
| Transaction fees | 0% on Growth & Scale plans | 0.5–2% on every plan, every tier |
| Trustpilot score | ⭐ 4.8/5 | ⭐ 3.6/5 |
| Community features | ClubCircles™, ClubDirectory™, ClubConnect™ | Spaces, events, AI member matching |
| Real-time messaging | ✓ ClubConnect™ (Scale plan) | ✓ Included |
| Member directories | ✓ ClubDirectory™ | ✗ Not available |
| Course / LMS depth | ✓ Full LMS with drip content | Limited: no native drip scheduling |
| WordPress integrations | ✓ WooCommerce, Easy Affiliate, PrettyLinks | ✗ Limited third-party integrations |
| Mobile app | AppKit add-on ($1,199/year) | Mighty Pro add-on (custom pricing) |
| Live streaming | ✗ Via third-party integrations | ✓ Built in |
| AI member matching | ✗ | ✓ People Magic |
What Is Mighty Networks?

Mighty Networks is a standalone community platform designed to bring together courses, memberships, and community features in one place, without requiring any technical setup.
It launched in 2017 and has built a loyal following among community builders, coaches, and creators who want a polished, mobile-first experience.
The platform revolves around “Spaces” (dedicated areas for different topics, cohorts, or groups) and its standout feature is “People Magic,” an AI engine that matches community members based on shared interests.
For community-first creators who don’t want to think about websites, hosting, or plugins, it’s a genuinely appealing option.
Where Mighty Networks runs into trouble is scale and cost. Transaction fees apply on every single plan (0.5–2%), the course tools are basic compared to a dedicated LMS, and the pricing climbs steeply as your needs grow.
And critically: your member data, your content, and your community all live on their servers. If they change their pricing, get acquired, or sunset the platform, you’re starting over.
What Is MemberPress?

MemberPress is a WordPress plugin that lets you build membership sites, sell online courses, coaching programs and (on the Growth and Scale plans) run a full community with discussion boards, member directories, and real-time messaging.
It sits on your WordPress site, which means you own your data, your content, and your member relationships outright.
There’s no platform dependency and no revenue share beyond standard payment processor fees on Growth and Scale plans.
For years, the knock on MemberPress in community comparisons was that it lacked built-in community tools.
That argument is now outdated.
ClubSuite™ is made up of
- ClubCircles™ – discussion boards,
- ClubDirectory™ – searchable member directories with map view, and ClubConnect™ – real-time group chat and direct messaging (Scale plan only)
and it puts MemberPress squarely in the same conversation as Mighty Networks.
The difference is it starts at $299.50/year instead of $948/year.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: Pricing
MemberPress Growth (which starts you off on community features) starts at $299.50/year with zero transaction fees. That’s for a full year, billed once.
Mighty Networks’ Launch plan starts at $79/month, which works out to $948/year. And that’s before transaction fees of 0.5–2% on every purchase your members make.
If you want advanced features like API integrations, you’re on the Scale plan at $179/month ($2,148/year).
MemberPress runs on WordPress, so you’ll need to factor in hosting and a domain name.
A reliable WordPress host typically runs $10–30/month ($120–$360/year) depending on your provider and traffic needs.
Add that to the MemberPress Growth license and you’re looking at roughly $420–$660/year all in.
Compare that to Mighty Networks’ Launch plan at $948/year, plus 0.5–2% transaction fees on top, and MemberPress still comes out significantly more cost effective, even after accounting for hosting.
And unlike Mighty Networks, you’re building on infrastructure you own and control.
Bottom line: Even with WordPress hosting factored in, MemberPress Growth typically costs less than Mighty Networks’ entry-level plan, and comes with zero transaction fees on Growth and Scale.
The pricing math still heavily favors MemberPress for anyone thinking long-term.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: Community Features
This used to be Mighty Networks’ strongest argument. It no longer is.
MemberPress’s ClubSuite™ includes:
- ClubCircles™ – private discussion boards where members can post updates, share files, and engage with each other, all inside your WordPress site
- ClubDirectory™ – searchable member profiles with map view, auto-enrollment, and the ability to create multiple directories based on skill, location, or membership tier
- ClubConnect™ – real-time group messaging and direct member-to-member chat with file sharing, @mentions, emoji reactions, and push notifications
Mighty Networks still leads on a few things: its “People Magic” AI matching for surfacing relevant connections between members is clever, and live events and streaming are built in natively.
But MemberPress now covers the core community functions (discussion, directories, and real-time messaging) that most community operators actually need.
Bottom line: If you need live streaming and AI-driven member matchmaking as core features, Mighty Networks has an edge. For everything else, MemberPress ClubSuite™ covers the ground, at a price that’s hard to argue with.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: Course and LMS Features
MemberPress wins this one cleanly.
MemberPress includes a full LMS with drip content scheduling, quizzes, progress tracking, course builder, and lesson-by-lesson access control.
You can release content on a schedule, lock it to specific membership tiers, and combine courses with community access in whatever configuration you need.
Mighty Networks added courses to a community platform rather than building a learning management system from the ground up.
The result is course hosting that handles video and basic structure but lacks native drip content scheduling.
It’s a meaningful gap for anyone running structured programs where pacing matters.
Bottom line: If courses are central to what you’re building, MemberPress is the stronger LMS.
Mighty Networks handles simple course hosting, but it wasn’t designed with learning management as its primary purpose.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: Integrations
Mighty Networks is a closed platform. So proper integrations that connect 2 systems are limited. They make it easy to embed snippets from external sites and apps on your site, though that’s easily done in WordPress too.
If you rely on tools like WooCommerce, an email service provider other than Kit, or your own affiliate program, you’ll find yourself working around the platform rather than with it.
MemberPress is built on WordPress, which integrates with essentially everything.
The native ecosystem includes dozens of integrations with popular apps and plugins plus thousands more via tools like Zapier and Uncanny Automator.
You also get access to the full WordPress plugin library – thousands of tools that work out of the box.
Bottom line: If your business runs on other tools, MemberPress plugs into them. Mighty Networks requires you to work within its walls.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: AI Features
Mighty Networks’ AI is mostly aimed at members. It suggests icebreakers, polishes posts and recommends hashtags. It has an MCP connection too, but it stops short of anything involving payments or paid access, so it can’t help with the business side of your community.
MemberPress’s AI is built to take work off your plate.
It helps you build courses. Ask your AI to draft lessons and quizzes straight into MemberPress Courses, so you’re editing rather than starting from a blank page.
It runs your membership site for you. Membership MCP, included with every MemberPress plan, gives your site its own MCP server. Connect an AI agent like Claude or ChatGPT, and the jobs you’d normally put off take seconds:
- “Which subscriptions failed to renew this week?”
- “Move Jane from the Basic plan to Premium.”
- “Set up a coupon for our founding members.”
You don’t have to dig through dashboards or export spreadsheets. You ask, your agent handles it, and anything risky, like a refund or a cancellation, waits for your approval.
Bottom line: Mighty’s AI helps your members talk to each other. MemberPress’s AI helps you build and run the whole business, on a site you own.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: Mobile App
Both platforms have a native mobile app solution – and both require extra investment to get one.
MemberPress offers AppKit, a white-labeled native iOS and Android app builder, as a $1,199/year add-on requiring a Growth or Scale plan.
It includes push notifications, in-app payments, and managed App Store publishing.
Mighty Networks offers a branded native app through Mighty Pro – their enterprise tier with custom pricing.
Standard plans ($79–$354/month) give members a mobile-accessible web experience, not a native branded app.
Both platforms have a native app path, and both involve additional cost beyond their standard plans.
Bottom line: It’s a tie. Neither platform bundles a branded native app into their standard pricing.
MemberPress AppKit is $1,199/year. Mighty Networks’ equivalent is Mighty Pro at custom enterprise pricing, neither option is dramatically simpler or cheaper than the other.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: Customer Satisfaction
MemberPress holds a 4.8/5 on Trustpilot. Mighty Networks currently sits at 3.5/5 on Trustpilot. Meaningfully lower, with recurring complaints about customer service responsiveness and refund policies.
On G2 and Capterra, Mighty Networks scores around 4.6/5, which is strong, but the Trustpilot gap suggests real friction at the post-sale stage.
A 4.8 vs. 3.6 gap on Trustpilot tends to reflect actual support experiences and overall product reliability. When something breaks or you need help scaling, you’ll be counting on that difference.

Bottom line: MemberPress’s customer satisfaction scores are consistently higher across platforms. Mighty Networks’ G2 and Capterra scores are good, but the Trustpilot gap is worth taking seriously.
MemberPress vs. Mighty Networks: Data Ownership
Mighty Networks holds your member data. Your community, your subscribers, and your content all live on their servers.
If they change their pricing model, get acquired, or shut down, your options are limited.
You can export some data, but you’re rebuilding your community from scratch.
MemberPress runs on WordPress. Your member data lives in a database you control, on hosting you pay for, at a domain you own.
You can migrate, export, back up, or move at any point. You’re not beholden to a third-party platform’s roadmap or pricing decisions.
Bottom line: If long-term business stability matters to you, WordPress ownership plus MemberPress is the safer bet. Mighty Networks’ convenience comes at the cost of control.
Who MemberPress Is Best For
- WordPress site owners who want to add membership, courses, and community without migrating to a new platform
- Course creators who need real LMS functionality – drip content, structured learning paths, and access control built into the same tool
- Coaches running paid communities who need CoachKit™ (accountability programs) alongside ClubSuite™ community features (Scale plan)
- Businesses with existing WooCommerce stores who want to layer in memberships and gated content
- Operators who want zero transaction fees at scale – Growth and Scale plans charge nothing beyond payment processor fees
- Anyone building for the long term who doesn’t want to be on a platform they don’t own
Who Mighty Networks Is Best For
- Non-technical creators who want a polished, all-in-one platform with no hosting setup
- Community-first builders for whom member engagement and connection (not courses) is the core product
- Creators who need live streaming built in and don’t want to wire up a third-party tool
Switching from Mighty Networks to MemberPress
Here’s how the switch works, step by step. Your Mighty network stays live the whole time, so you can move everyone over when you’re ready.
- Export your members from Mighty. Download your member list as a spreadsheet from your Mighty admin, and grab your course videos and files while you’re there.
- Create your memberships. Set up one MemberPress membership for each Mighty plan.
- Import your members. The MemberPress Importer, included on every plan, adds everyone to the right membership, paying members included. They just set a new password the first time they log in.
- Add your rules. Decide which content each membership unlocks.
- Style your site with ReadyLaunch™. It sets up your login, account and checkout pages in a few clicks, so everything looks finished when members arrive.
- Rebuild your courses. Upload your videos to MemberPress Courses and add your lessons around them.
- Start your community. Set up ClubCircles™ forums to match your Mighty Spaces. Your old posts stay on Mighty, so open with a welcome thread and invite your most active members in first to get the conversation going.
Frequently Asked Questions
MemberPress is dramatically cheaper ($299.50/year vs. $948+/year), has no transaction fees on Growth and Scale plans, and now includes full community features via ClubSuite™.
Mighty Networks has an edge on built-in live streaming, but MemberPress wins on cost, data ownership, and LMS depth.
Mighty Networks is a closed SaaS platform where your community lives on their servers.
MemberPress focuses on memberships and courses with community as an add-on (ClubSuite™).
Mighty Networks leads with community and adds courses secondarily.
MemberPress Growth and Scale plans include discussion boards (ClubCircles™), member directories (ClubDirectory™), with real-time messaging (ClubConnect™) available only on Scale.
These features cover the core community features most Mighty Networks users rely on.
The main gap is built-in live streaming and Mighty Networks’ AI member-matching feature.
AppKit delivers a white-labeled native iOS and Android app builder with push notifications, in-app purchases, and managed App Store publishing.
It’s an additional cost, not included by default.
MemberPress Growth (the community-enabled plan) starts at $299.50/year with no transaction fees.
Mighty Networks’ entry-level plan is $79/month ($948/year) and still charges 0.5–2% transaction fees on every sale.
Even factoring in WordPress hosting, MemberPress costs a fraction of Mighty Networks’ cheapest option.
MemberPress scores 4.8/5 on Trustpilot, a meaningful gap that reflects real user experiences post-purchase.
MemberPress’s customer success team can guide you through the process, and ReadyLaunch™ can get the core setup running quickly.
It’s a more complete course-building tool than Mighty Networks, which added courses onto a community platform rather than building an LMS from the start.
The Verdict
Mighty Networks built its reputation as the go-to platform for online communities. That reputation was earned, but the gap has narrowed considerably.
With ClubSuite™, MemberPress now offers discussion boards, member directories, and real-time messaging on a platform you actually own, at a price that’s roughly three times lower than Mighty Networks’ entry plan.
If you’re a non-technical creator who wants an all-in-one hosted platform with no WordPress setup, Mighty Networks is worth considering.
But if you’re building a real business on WordPress, one where your member data, your content, and your revenue stay yours, MemberPress is the stronger long-term choice.
Ready to see what MemberPress can do for your community? Try MemberPress risk-free for 14 days.
Get MemberPress Today!
Start getting paid for the content you create.


Add a Comment